What Does Science Say About The Existence Of Ghosts/Spirits ? 👻

avatar
(Edited)

halloween-g25dea278d_1920.jpg
Source
Have you seen a ghost before ? Have I seen a ghost before ? Have we all seen a ghost before ?

Those questions seem very hard to answer, even though some of us may claim otherwise. Personally, i'm having a hard time understanding what a ghost really is, probably because i'm very analytical or an overthinker if you would put it that way. But this is not to say ghosts may not exist, it depends on the kind of ghost you are talking about.
Ghost has different meanings depending on the context it's associated with but it's mostly associated with a part of matter beyond physical reality. In religion, it's also considered a "spirit" or soul and it's mostly a part of man beyond physical reality whose existence is relatively eternal unlike the body that eventually decays. In philosophy, it's also considered a soul and mostly associated with the mind - the supposed seat of intelligence, emotions and other mental states.
In philosophy, the soul/mind can also be extended beyond humans, animals and even non-living objects like a stone too can possess a soul/mind. This may seem absurd, how can a stone have a soul ?
This is possible thanks to the "mind-body problem" which happens to be under the "philosophy of mind". This problem has been vexing philosophers and scientists for ages, it has to do with the nature of the mind (is it of a substance beyond our physical reality ?), how it (the mind) "is connected to" and "interacts with" the physical body. Philosophical questions like this laid grounds for the existence of neuroscience and cognitive science. Philosophically speaking, those two scientific fields arose from physicalism/materialism, which happens to be one of the many philosophical schools of thought attempting to resolve the mind-body dilemma. So, in science, when discussing about ghost/spirit/soul, we are simply discussing about the mind, though to some extent is related to the religious kind. According to physicalism, there's nothing in reality that is beyond what we observe physically or in other words, what we believe to be the mind/soul can be or should be explainable with physical laws. This is why most of the time when people talk about seeing ghosts or any paranormal phenomenon, scientists would tell you it's your brain making up stuffs due to certain physical factors.
Physicalism and science dismisses the existence of entities/forces beyond our physical reality or does it ?

I must have in one of my previous articles told us that science relies on philosophy, this is from a foundational perspective, the philosophy accompanying modern science is physicalism and unfortunately, there seems to be possibilities of physicalism having limits. In other words, there seems to be stuffs about our reality physicalism cannot handle with great satisfaction, an example is "the hard problem of consciousness" this is another philosophical question in the philosophy of mind. The hard problem of consciousness presents us with the question of why and how we have subjective consciousness or why certain experience appears different for different individuals - this would be an article for another time. Another problem is that while science has been able to show through experimentation the correlation between mental states and physical states (in the brain) which partly supports physicalism, it is yet to be known from experiment what the first cause is, another way of putting it is, does the mind control the brain or does the brain control the mind ? 😂

As if those aren't enough, quantum mechanics which happens to be a theory of our fundamental physical reality seems to be suggesting a limit to physicalism. In our previous article where we discussed about the "Schrödinger's cat experiment", we also briefly highlighted some of the problems with quantum mechanic, those problems could be as a result of one of two reasons which are

  • The mathematical model of quantum mechanics being flawed due to incompleteness

  • The mathematical model is accurate but science (physicalism) has gotten to it's limit or not all of reality can be realized through experimentation.

The second reason offers room for the existence of entities beyond our physical reality - like the mysterious wave function used in calculations of quantum mechanics, ghosts too are included since they are also believed to be beyond our physical reality.
Don't totally buy into the idea of science disproving the existence of ghosts, the truth is that there are serious conflicts with science and it's methods. It's still at a point where it can't give a definitive answer but this is not to say we shouldn't trust it. For now, science is still our best approach to understanding our reality and i believe there's room for further development, including it's philosophy.

For Further Reading

Soul

Philosophy of mind

The science of ghosts

What Science & Quantum Physics Say About Whether Or Not Ghosts Are Real

Thank you all once again for stopping by to read my jargons and also thank you @stemng, @lemouth and the @Steemstem team for your valuable supports.

FUkUE5bzkAZT3HzV5tJDiU2ik81PCd4JCyhWnRcDN8XJsVFY3UNB8DCS995wPwk4NK9xZ2qAaiN4mtnT9egYmuvf5Ckv5nmHwyWLKV3ubxhJyNf5VkN4aDKpqLyH679S4V2SmfjuLSieAVK2xBYWmqkfN65hmMkx1iwQ.png
Source

Lastly, please don't forget to do the needful
Upvote
Comment
Reblog
If you enjoyed my jargons.

IMG_20230217_004227.jpg
Background image source by @doze



0
0
0.000
13 comments
avatar

Just because something is "quantum" does not make it supernatural or special. Pseudoscientists and pseudo-philosophers cling to the unfair reputation of quantum mechanics of being "mysterious" to pretend to give plausibility to their antiquated and currently pseudoscientific idea that we possess souls that survive the body. It is an invention of the ancient Greeks in their ancient ignorance which was then exported to Judaism during the Babylonian exile and then, thousands of years later, exported to Christianity and Islam. That is why everyone today speaks of souls and spirits, unaware that it is an inherited superstition. Today we know better. Consciousness is a very complicated physical process and as such does not necessarily deserve an explanation from physicists in the same way as digestion does not need a physicist to explain it.

0
0
0.000
avatar

I have nothing much to say about your arguments, this is not to say you're are wrong though but it seems like you're a hardcore physicalist. Everyone is entitled to their own school of thought. 😎

0
0
0.000
avatar

It is more than being a physicalist. It is having the conclusive empirical, documentary and archaeological data that point to the worldly origin of the belief in souls and spirits. Some pseudoscientists no longer believe that the earth is supported by turtles or that the universe is made of fire, earth, air and water, as was commonly understood long ago, but somehow want to make an exception for other "obsolete models" (to put it mildly) such as that of body/soul dualism. If I were religious, I would argue that those who believe in these things are committing apostasy, since they actually believe in pagan Greek superstitions. And actually there are Christians out there who think so.

0
0
0.000
avatar

Thanks for your contribution to the STEMsocial community. Feel free to join us on discord to get to know the rest of us!

Please consider delegating to the @stemsocial account (85% of the curation rewards are returned).

Thanks for including @stemsocial as a beneficiary, which gives you stronger support. 
 

0
0
0.000
avatar

I just used this quote in a post of mind. If you're into philosophy, you should give Popper a go. Although I'm sure if you are, you probably have already heard of him.

“In so far as a scientific statement speaks about reality, it must be falsifiable: and in so far as it is not falsifiable, it does not speak about reality.”

0
0
0.000
avatar
(Edited)

I'm very much interested in philosophy but in an unorthodox way. I have actually come across the name Karl Popper before but i'm not very familiar with his works. These days scientists make it seem as though science and philosophy are completely distinct or make philosophy seem obsolete. I shall do further digging, thanks for the recommendation. 😉

0
0
0.000
avatar

Well the old saying goes:
Biology is applied chemistry, chemistry is applied physics, physics is applied math, and math is applied philosophy. It all has to start somewhere. Everything is connected in some way. The philosophy of science is very interesting actually.

0
0
0.000
avatar

The philosophy of science is very interesting actually.

It is indeed.

0
0
0.000
avatar

While I have never seen a ghost, I have read stories of people who claimed they have seen one, it is really a lot but at the end of the day, everyone remains entitled to their own opinions. Thanks for the post.

0
0
0.000
avatar

everyone remains entitled to their own opinions.

Very true.

Thanks for the post.

You're welcome

0
0
0.000
avatar

While I have never seen a ghost, I have read stories of people who claimed they have seen one, it is really a lot but at the end of the day, everyone remains entitled to their own opinions. Thanks for the post.

0
0
0.000
avatar

James Randi, one of the most influential magicians of the 21st century, was a great detractor of this pseudo-idea in popular culture; the belief in spirits or ghosts. In fact, he created the challenge of a million dollars to anyone who, on a demonstrable and irrefutable scientific basis, could prove the measurable and tangible existence of such a thing as "a ghost or spirit". Genius. Sorry but I decided to leave this little piece of information for you here. Excellent work, my friend. @clinton19

0
0
0.000